In this cross-country battle of slight seers, which rodent reigns supreme?

Flatiron Freddy, in front of his namesake formations. Courtesy City of Boulder

Editor’s note: This article was originally published Saturday, Jan. 30, 2021. It is being reprinted for Groundhog Day 2023. Flatiron Freddy saw his shadow this year, predicting — per usual — six more weeks of winter.

As the sun dawns on Groundhog Day 2021, two iconoclasts of meteorology will pit their prognosticating powers against one another, continuing one of the country’s most enduring east-versus-west battles.

On the east coast (rather, roughly 300 miles inland) and rising two hours earlier is Punxsutawney Phil, the heavyweight of this forecasting contest. Phil has nearly every available advantage: A legacy that spans more than a century and spawned a classic Hollywood film adored by millions (particularly Buddhists); a line of merch; and his own inner circle of top-hatted handlers and hype men.

Phil’s appearance every Feb. 2 draws tens of thousands of fans. His annual prophecies are why there is a Groundhog Day to begin with, the literal reason for the season.*

He’s also a real, live groundhog.

Boulder’s own Flatiron Freddy is, well, neither. A yellow bellied marmot, Freddy is stuffed — not with the secret wisdom of unforetold weather events, but with actual stuffing, having died some years ago.**

How much rock can a rock chuck rock — or chuck?

Phil and Freddy are cousins. Groundhogs (Marmota monax) and yellow-bellied marmots (Marmota flaviventris) are cousins, related species under the genus marmota, family sciuridae and order rodentia. 

Yellow-bellied marmots are sometimes also known as rock chucks.

Though he may be lacking in international acclaim and certain faculties of the living, Freddy has his claw on the pulse of something Phil could use a bit more of: A reliant method of prediction.

Human handlers for Phil and Freddy claim 100% accuracy rates for their respective rodents. But an exclusive investigation from Boulder Beat — two phone calls, three emails, one Google search and some math — reveals that Flatiron Freddy is right more than twice as often as the Grand Poobah of Gobbler’s Knob.

To err is human; to forgive, diviner

Pre-prophesying routines for the slight seers are remarkably similar. Both involve scrolls and, usually, poems. Both also require human assistance — to the detriment of Phil’s reputation as an augur of atmospheric conditions.

Two tomes are presented to Phil on the morning of his big guess. Once placed on his stump, Phil consorts with the cosmos and divines the fate of millions. It is then the job of the Inner Circle’s president — this year, Jeffrey Lundy — to “communicate with Phil” using “Groundhogese,” a language “very much like animal sign language,” according to Lundy.

“It’s not actual words,” Lundy said. “It’s winks and nods.”

It has happened in the past that Phil’s divination gets lost in translation, accounting for the groundhog’s abysmal accuracy. As reported by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (which has a division in Boulder; point Freddy), the National Climactic Data Center and the Canadian Weather Service, Phil correctly predicts pending weather about 40% of the time.

“Sometimes, you can get it wrong,” said Lundy, who will be making his first-ever interpretation this year. “Phil will get it right. Hopefully I get it right.”

Phil is remarkably accommodating when presidents muddle his predictions, Lundy said, a grace that has come with age.

“Twenty or 30 years ago, he was a little more sensitive than he is now. He’s pretty mellow.”

Image by Chris Flook via Wikimedia Commons

It’s always sunny in Boulder

Freddy makes his debut with only one scroll in paw, having already foreseen the future from the comfort of his burrow. Freddy generally chooses to arrive in style: He’s been known to fly in via zipline, parachute and gondola; roll up in a monster truck; or — when he’s feeling more active — ski to his morning appointment with dozens of adoring fans.

Official records of Freddy’s conjectures aren’t kept. According to handler and OSMP Ranger Dave Gustafson, Freddy’s partnership with the city began around 2008. A massive snowfall led to the event’s cancellation one year, resulting in just about a decade of active forecasting. Only once does Gustafson recall Freddy presaging an early spring.

Assuming Gustafson’s recollections are correct, Boulder’s beloved mountain marmot boasts a 90% success rate. In this, Freddy far surpasses Phil, and is perhaps the most accurate ground-dwelling mammal in all of America.***

Freddy’s secret is simple. Winter weather in Colorado is typically predictable in that our snowiest months come in the spring. And with over 300 days of sun a year, Feb. 2 is usually clear and bright: prime shadow-casting conditions.

“The majority of the times that I remember,” Gustafson said, “it’s always been sunny.”

Flatiron Freddy enjoys an active afterlife in Boulder. (Courtesy City of Boulder)

A dire prediction

This year’s festivities will look a little different for both Freddy and Phil. They will have to make their prognostications sans a live crowd, an important safety measure during COVID. Phil will do his divining before a cadre of cardboard cutouts; Freddy will be surrounded by intimate friends and family only. Both will be attended by camera crews.

Neither rodent has been ruffled by the friendly competition between them, handlers said. Least of all Phil.

Said Lundy, “If you’re the queen of England, you don’t get upset if someone else calls themselves queen. You know you’re the queen.”

Plus, Lundy adds, while Freddy’s hunches are confined to Colorado, Phil’s are global. In other words, it’s always spring somewhere.

With the effects of climate change, said Gustafson, that’s unfortunately true. And it’s causing the ranks of fuzzy forecasters to expand — literally.

“Groundhogs are a great predictor of how we’re treating the earth,” Gustafson said. “They’re more obese in certain areas because they’re not sleeping as much. They’re coming out and eating more.”

While we’ll have to wait and see what the skies say Feb. 2, Freddy is ready with a dire warning that extends far beyond this winter, to the fate of the planet itself. 

Said Gustafson, “His prediction is if we don’t turn things around, things are going to get pretty bad” — for marmots and humans alike.

*Groundhog Day, like many American holidays, has pagan roots. Feb. 2 is halfway between the winter solstice and spring equinox, making it an auspicious day for celebrations of impending spring. Celts celebrated it as Imbolc; European Christians later called it Candlemas. The first Groundhog Day was indeed in Punxsutawney, Pa., purportedly presided over by the same Phil responsible for Tuesday’s affair. According to Lundy, Phil is 135 years old.

**Freddy is also more than a century old — “centuries,” according to Gustafson. Cave drawings depict Freddy prognosticating to indigenous peoples. His after-life began one characteristically sunny day in 1977, the legend goes, on the then-open-to-traffic Pearl Street. Freddy was, per usual in his offseason, dodging cars for cash and the delight of onlookers, when tragedy — in the form of a VW bus — struck. Outraged by his death, Boulderites moved to make Pearl Street pedestrian-only, birthing the walking mall we all know and love today and cementing Freddy’s Forrest Gump-like predilection for moving the wheels of history forward.

***No word on how Freddy stacks up against Lander Lil, Wyoming’s soothsaying prairie dog and the only female forecaster on these lists. Like many of her peers, Lil claims 100% accuracy.

— Shay Castle,, @shayshinecastle

Want more stories like this, delivered straight to your inbox? Click here to sign up for a weekly newsletter from Boulder Beat.


Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: