Xcel, Boulder reach muni-ending deal for voters to weigh this fall

pexels-photo-918989Tuesday, July 28, 2020 (Updated Monday, Aug. 3)

After mere months of negotiation — and a decade-plus march toward municipalization — Boulder and Xcel Energy have reached a deal that will re-establish a franchise agreement; that is, if voters approve it in November. The settlement preserves the right to establish a city-run electric utility in the future and asserts that a Boulder powered by 100% renewables by 2030 is possible, though that might require a vote of the people to repurpose and extend a muni-funding tax toward pilot projects.

The agreement, announced Tuesday night, includes upgrading Boulder’s physical infrastructure, allowing for local distribution and more renewables, and promises $33 million in “under grounding” — burying overhead power lines, which increases reliability — that was put off while Boulder was out of franchise.

Most crucially, it provides numerous options for Boulder to opt out of a franchise agreement, and resume municipalization efforts, if Xcel doesn’t make good on its pledge to reduce carbon emissions 80% by 2030. The company has yet to file plans with state regulators, but once it does, Xcel will be bound by them. Any variances would have to be granted by the Public Utilities Commission, according to spokesperson Terry Bote.

Specific to carbon reduction, voters can end the franchise in 2023, 2025 and 2028 if adequate progress isn’t being made. Additionally, the franchise can be ended by a vote of the people “without any reason” in 2026, 2031 and 2036, according to a staff presentation. There are also state-mandated opt-outs at 10 and 15 years; franchise agreements last for a period of 20 years.

Read a live-tweet thread of Tuesday night’s discussion

Boulder was last an Xcel franchisee in 2010. Voters allowed that to lapse in January 2011, that same year passing two measures authorizing the city to form a utility and condemn Xcel’s physical assets and funding those efforts through an expansion of the Utility Occupation Tax.

Voters will have to OK this settlement. If they don’t, the next chance to weigh in on Boulder’s energy future will be 2022. Because of the way the UOT is structured, the municipalization effort — which the city calls Local Power — will need to borrow $2.2 million from the general fund next year, to be repaid in 2022.

If a franchise agreement is re-established, the muni-funding portion of the UOT will terminate. City Attorney Tom Carr is recommending that council ask voters to repurpose and possibly extend the tax to fund certain pilot projects, such as hydrogen storage and net-zero development at Alpine-Balsam.

More than $27.5 million has been spent on the muni since 2012, all in pursuit of a final answer to the question: How much will it cost to buy Xcel’s lines, poles, transformers, substations, etc. and get a city-owned electric utility up and running? (Plus the cost to repair/replace Xcel infrastructure needed to keep serving customers outside city limits.)

Some major proceedings need to conclude before that question is answered, including a court case condemning Xcel’s system and a federal ruling on the future of a transmission loop. As part of the agreement, Boulder will dismiss a pending condemnation case and federal regulatory proceedings.

The city first filed for condemnation in 2014. The dismissal of that case sent the city to the PUC, a process that wrapped only last year. Delays have pushed back the launch of a municipal utility: It was supposed to be operational by 2016, then 2017, then 2022, according to a decade of Daily Camera coverage.

Now, staff maintains it can be operational by 2025, and powered by 100% renewable energy by 2030 — Boulder’s goal and part of its climate commitments. The city recently launched a competitive bidding process seeking power providers. Bids are due Aug. 14 and so should be available ahead of November’s election.

Boulder is bound by a few restraints, based on a 2011 vote of the people that embedded certain conditions in the city’s charter. A municipal utility would have to provide reliable service at rates equal to Xcel’s, bringing in enough revenue to cover the cost of acquisition plus debt plus 25%. Voters also set a hard cap on the debt that can be issued to pay for the purchase at $214 million, to be adjusted for inflation.

Critics doubt that Boulder can do so, noting delays and cost increases of this and other city projects. Proponents of municipalization reserve their skepticism for Xcel, questioning the company’s commitment to renewables and ratepayers.

Part of the agreement with Xcel actually sets a lower limit for acquisition, at $200 million. That cap includes going concern: profits Xcel won’t make once Boulder is no longer a customer. Xcel has estimated going concern at $350 million in the past; the city has insisted that, based on a Florida court case, it won’t be obligated to pay for future lost profits.

Not included in that $200 million are stranded costs, monies owed to Xcel by Boulder based on the company’s plans to have the city as a customer and the investments made in light of that assumption. Xcel believes stranded costs will be valued between $300-$400 million, Carr said Tuesday night. Boulder has consistently argued that stranded costs could be zero or that it could pay them over time by purchasing power back from Xcel.

First reading of both measures — a settlement and repurposing of the UOT — is scheduled for Aug. 4. A public hearing on the deal will be held at a special meeting Thursday, Aug. 20. Council will have to vote to send the agreement to Boulder voters. They expressed support for that this week.

Author’s note: This article has been updated with additional comments from Tuesday’s discussion and to reflect the rescheduling of the public hearing.

City council meeting: 6 p.m. Tuesday, Aug. 4. Watch live online or on Channel 8.

— Shay Castle, boulderbeatnews@gmail.com, @shayshinecastle

Want more stories like this, delivered straight to your inbox? Click here to sign up for a weekly newsletter from Boulder Beat.

Elections Municipalization

9 Comments Leave a comment

  1. Time line correction:

    Boulder was last an Xcel franchisee in 2010. Voters allowed that to lapse in a 2010 vote. In 2011 Boulder voters passed two measures authorizing the city to explore forming a utility and funding those efforts through an expansion of the Utility Occupation Tax.

  2. What a relief. Boulder will vote to end the Loony Muni very easily this November. Why? Because the City has failed over and over again to demonstrate any competence either legally or financially. The fact that the City Manager is leaving is also a good sign since it was her leadership on this along with the long gone Heather Bailey that sent us into this maelstrom of self deceit. If you have any questions about the details about the bad leadership, bad legal decisions or financial shenanigans, go to EndTheMuni.org.

  3. It is not clear in your article that the City Council has to agree to put this on the ballot. That has not yet occurred and there have been three previous negotiated agreements that City Council has refused to put on the ballot.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: